NewsCord Analysis of 51,000+ BBC Programmes Finds Presenters Argued Israel's Case Six Times More Often Than Palestinians'
A news-monitoring platform's review of three years of BBC Gaza coverage finds presenters voicing Israel's defense in 252 interviews against just 15 for the Palestinian side.
Source: The New Arab · published November 11, 2026
A platform that compares news outlets' coverage says it has quantified something Palestinian advocates have long alleged about the BBC: that the broadcaster does not just report Israel's position, it argues it.
NewsCord, a news comparison service, examined 51,303 BBC News programmes aired between October 7, 2023 and November 4, 2026, along with 1,618 written articles. The investigation, titled "BBC: Would Say Files," counted how often presenters put Israel's case to guests critical of its conduct in Gaza, and how often they did the reverse for Israel's defenders.
The tally: 252 interviews in which presenters voiced Israel's defense, against 15 in which they presented the Palestinian case to guests defending Israel. Critics of Israel's conduct appeared roughly two and a half times more often than defenders, but once that imbalance is factored in, presenters argued on Israel's behalf in 9.8 percent of interviews with critics, compared with 1.5 percent of interviews with defenders, according to the NewsCord data.
Nima Akram, the platform's CEO and founder, told The New Arab the practice goes beyond standard put-the-other-side journalism because presenters often invoked Israel's position without Israeli officials having said anything themselves.
"The term 'Israel would say' is also highly problematic, because it shows that the BBC is doing Israel's bidding for it, without even using Israeli statements," Akram said. "They are simply coming to their defence without Israel needing to say anything."
The report cites a October 7, 2023 interview with Palestinian politician Mustafa Barghouti, in which a presenter told him: "Israel would say you elected Hamas, which is an organisation committed to the destruction of Israel, and therefore they have to implement security. That is what they would say." NewsCord counted 75 interviews using some version of "Israel would say" against critics, compared with four uses of "Palestinians would say" directed at Israel's defenders.
The written-article sample showed a similar pattern. A Palestinian position followed an Israeli claim in 25 percent of cases, NewsCord found, while an Israeli response followed a criticism of Israel in 49 percent of cases. When Hamas or Gaza authorities made a claim, Israel's position was included 58 percent of the time; when the Israeli government made a claim, a Palestinian or UN position was included in only 39 percent of cases.
NewsCord also reviewed whether presenters, in those 252 interviews where they argued Israel's case, raised statements by senior Israeli officials bearing on allegations of collective punishment and starvation. The report lists five such statements, including Netanyahu's and Gallant's, and found only one instance, a November 20, 2023 interview with historian Omer Bartov, in which a presenter raised Gallant's description of Palestinians as "human animals." Guests themselves raised one of the five statements in four other interviews; in the remaining 247, none went mentioned.
Akram said the BBC's defense of its practice as balanced journalism does not hold given the disparity. "We agree that putting the other side's case is legitimate. The BBC does it for one side," he told The New Arab.
The figures come from a single outside analysis; Occupation Watch has not independently verified NewsCord's dataset or methodology, and no BBC response to the findings was included in the reporting reviewed.
Sources & Documentation
- BBC 'doing Israel's bidding' in Gaza coverage, report finds — The New ArabPrimary source, cites NewsCord 'BBC: Would Say Files' investigation
Related Coverage

Austria Holds Gaza Now Founder Mustafa Ayyash in Pre-Trial Detention Under Anti-Terror Statute
Mustafa Ayyash, founder of Gaza news outlet Gaza Now, has been held in Austrian pre-trial detention since November 2025 under a terror statute critics say criminalizes Palestine journalism.

Planet Labs Made Gulf Satellite Imagery Restrictions Indefinite After US Government Request, Cutting Off a Key Tool for Verifying Wartime Strikes
Planet Labs made its satellite imagery blackout over Iran and the Gulf indefinite at the US government's request, alarming open-source analysts who use such imagery to verify wartime damage.

Israel Paid a PR Firm to Build a Fake Think Tank That Feeds AI Chatbots Pro-Israel Talking Points
A think tank with no bylines and 100+ articles in a week was built by an Israeli-funded PR firm to manipulate AI chatbot answers on Israel and Gaza.
